How to Choose an SEO Agency: Finding the Ideal Partner for Your Business

creative click media logo 2019

If you’re reading this, there’s a good chance you’re considering hiring an SEO agency. Congratulations! That’s a huge step toward improving your online presence and reaching more potential customers. Of course, deciding to work with an SEO agency is only the beginning of the journey – the real challenge lies in finding the right SEO agency to work with.

Choosing an SEO agency is a lot like choosing a business partner: it requires a great deal of research, careful consideration and trust-building to ensure a successful relationship. So where do you start? We put together this comprehensive guide on how to choose an SEO agency for your business:

Before You Start: Preparing to Choose an SEO Agency

Now that you’ve decided it’s time to find an SEO agency, you might be eager to dive right in. But before you start your search, it’s important to lay a solid foundation. Think of it like preparing to buy a car—you wouldn’t head to the dealership without knowing your budget or the features you need before making such a big investment. Similarly, before you begin your search for an SEO agency, there are a few key steps to take. Here are some pre-search tasks to ensure you’re ready to find the perfect fit for your business:

Assess Your Needs

Start by determining your SEO goals and what you want to achieve. Are you looking to increase organic traffic, improve keyword rankings, or boost conversions? Understanding your goals will help you communicate effectively with potential agencies. Additionally, consider your budget and timeline for results. SEO is an ongoing process, so it’s important to have a realistic budget and timeframe in mind.

Educate Yourself About SEO

It’s essential to gain a basic understanding of SEO practices and terminology. Familiarize yourself with concepts like keywords, backlinks, and on-page optimization. Knowing the basics will not only help you understand what an SEO agency is offering but also enable you to ask informed questions and make better decisions for your business. It’s also important to go into this knowing what SEO results and timelines look like. SEO is not a quick fix, so be prepared for gradual improvements over time rather than overnight success.

Define Your Criteria

What are you looking for in an SEO agency besides results? Make a list of must-have features, such as experience, expertise, communication style and the ability to tailor strategies to your specific needs. Set realistic expectations based on your goals, budget and timeline. While you want to aim high, it’s essential to understand what is achievable within your constraints. By establishing clear criteria beforehand, you’ll be better equipped to vet potential SEO agencies and find the right partner for your business.

how to choose an SEO agency

Starting Your Search: What to Look For in an SEO Agency

Now that you’ve done your preliminary research, it’s time to start your search for an SEO agency. This step is crucial, as choosing the right agency can have a significant impact on your website’s visibility and success. However, with so many agencies out there, it can be overwhelming to know where to start. 

No pressure, right?

This section will guide you through the process of finding and evaluating potential SEO agencies so you can identify the key factors to consider and ensure you make an informed decision that aligns with your goals.

A Proven Track Record

One of the first things to look for in an SEO agency is a proven track record of success. Look for case studies or client testimonials showcasing successful SEO campaigns. This will give you an idea of the agency’s capabilities and the results they can deliver. Additionally, consider the agency’s longevity and reputation in the industry. An agency that has been around for a while and has a good reputation is likely to be a safer choice than a new agency with no tangible results or happy clients to show off.

Transparency and Communication

Clear communication is essential when working with an SEO agency. Seek out agencies with clear communication channels and a reputation for responsiveness – struggling to receive timely responses as a potential client can signal potential communication issues down the line. You should also look for agencies that provide regular reporting and updates on the progress of your SEO campaigns. This will help you track the success of your campaigns and ensure that the agency is delivering on their promises.

Customized SEO Strategies

Every business is unique, and your SEO strategy should reflect that. Look for an agency that offers tailored SEO strategies based on your business goals and industry. Steer clear of agencies that rely on generic, one-size-fits-all approaches, as these are unlikely to deliver the targeted results your business needs.

Ethical SEO Practices

Have you ever considered the ethical standards of SEO practices? While it might not be a topic that crosses your mind often, it’s crucial to select an SEO agency that makes it a priority. The ethical choices made by an agency can have a profound impact on your website’s performance and reputation over time. Studies show that websites employing ethical SEO techniques are 75% less likely to experience ranking fluctuations and penalties compared to those using unethical black hat tactics. Needless to say, it’s important to partner with an agency that adheres to ethical standards and complies with search engine guidelines, such as Google’s Search Essentials.

Technical Expertise

SEO is a technical field, so it’s important to work with an agency that has a strong understanding of technical SEO elements. When evaluating SEO agencies, prioritize those with a solid grasp of technical SEO elements such as website structure, mobile-friendliness and site speed optimization. A proficient agency should be capable of conducting thorough SEO audits to identify issues and implement necessary fixes efficiently. This technical expertise ensures that your website not only ranks well, but also delivers a seamless user experience that ultimately contributes to your online success.

Content and Link Building

When it comes to SEO, quality content and effective link building are paramount. A reputable agency should prioritize creating and optimizing high-quality content tailored to your audience’s needs. Additionally, they should employ strategies to acquire relevant and authoritative backlinks, enhancing your website’s credibility and visibility in search engine results. These efforts provide a powerful one-two punch of improving your search rankings and establishing your website as a valuable resource within your industry.

Red Flags: Signs of an Unreliable SEO Agency

Just like in any relationship, it’s important to watch out for red flags when choosing an SEO agency. Picking the wrong agency could mean wasting your time and money, or even damaging your website’s reputation and rankings. Keep an eye out for some common red flags to look for that will help you avoid potential pitfalls and make a smart choice for your business. By staying alert to these warning signs, you can find an agency that will truly benefit your website and online presence.

Guaranteed Rankings

Some SEO agencies may promise specific ranking positions within a short period, but no agency can guarantee rankings. It’s important to remember that SEO is an ongoing process, and if an agency is making such promises, it’s most likely a red flag that they are going to overpromise and underdeliver. Look for an agency that makes realistic projections, such as “results in 3-6 months” rather than “first page of Google in 3-6 weeks”. It takes an average of 3.1 months to start seeing any effect on your search rankings, so any agency promising less is untrustworthy.

Lack of Transparency

Transparency is crucial when working with an SEO agency. If an agency provides vague explanations of their SEO strategies and tactics, or is unwilling to share past performance data or client references, it could indicate that they have something to hide. A reputable agency should be open and transparent about their methods and be willing to provide evidence of their success.

Overemphasis on Low Prices

While staying in-budget is important, an overemphasis on low prices could be a warning sign that the quality of work may be compromised. Extremely low prices compared to other agencies may indicate that the agency is cutting corners or using outdated, ineffective tactics that could harm your website in the long run. It’s crucial to strike a balance between cost and quality when choosing an SEO agency to ensure the best results for your website.

Black-Hat Practices

Using black-hat SEO tactics such as keyword stuffing, cloaking or buying links can lead to penalties from search engines and damage your website’s reputation. If an agency mentions these tactics or you suspect they are using them, it’s best to steer clear. Make it a point to work with an agency that employs ethical white-hat SEO practices to avoid risking your credibility and rankings. Google clearly outlines all of the SEO practices they flag in their spam policy, so working with an agency who disregards these will likely harm your placement on a Google search.

seo marketing agency

How to Choose an SEO Agency: Start Here

Now that you know what to look for – and what not to look for! – in an SEO agency, the next step is to reach out and start the conversation.

Fortunately, we’re here to help.

With our proven track record, transparent communication and ethical practices, the Creative Click Media team is dedicated to helping your business develop a high-ranking SEO strategy. Think of us as your trusted partner in navigating the complex world of SEO. Expertise, reliability and results are only a click away – contact us and take the next step towards optimizing your online presence.


Q: How do I determine my SEO goals?

A: Start by identifying what you want to achieve with your SEO efforts. Are you looking to increase organic traffic, improve keyword rankings or boost conversions? Understanding your goals will help you communicate effectively with potential agencies and set clear expectations for your SEO strategy.

Q: How can I set realistic expectations for my SEO campaign?

A: Setting realistic expectations involves understanding what is achievable within your goals, budget, and timeline. Consider the competitiveness of your industry and the current state of your website’s SEO. A reputable SEO agency will help you set realistic goals and provide a clear roadmap for achieving them.

Q: What are ethical SEO practices, and why are they important?

A: Ethical SEO practices are strategies and tactics that adhere to search engine guidelines and prioritize the user experience. It’s important to partner with an agency that employs ethical practices to avoid penalties from search engines and maintain your website’s reputation and rankings.

Q: Why is technical expertise important when choosing an SEO agency?

A: SEO is technical process by nature, so it’s important to work with an agency that has a strong understanding of technical SEO elements such as website structure, mobile-friendliness and site speed optimization. This expertise ensures that your website not only ranks well, but also delivers a seamless user experience.

Q: Can an SEO agency guarantee specific ranking positions?

A: No reputable SEO agency can guarantee specific ranking positions. SEO is an ongoing process, and realistic projections involve gradual improvements rather than immediate, specific outcomes. If an SEO agency promises results that sound too good to be true, they probably are.

Start typing and press Enter to search

Social Media Graphic Sizes